Logo image
A randomized equivalence trial comparing the i-gel™ and laryngeal mask airway Supreme™ in children
Journal article   Peer reviewed

A randomized equivalence trial comparing the i-gel™ and laryngeal mask airway Supreme™ in children

Narasimhan Jagannathan, Katherine Sommers, Lisa E. Sohn, Amod Sawardekar, Ravi D. Shah, Isabella I. Mukherji, Steven Miller, Polina Voronov and Sally Seraphin
Paediatric Anaesthesia, Vol.23(2)
2013

Abstract

Airway Management Anesthesia, Inhalation Child Child, Preschool Data Interpretation, Statistical Female Fiber Optic Technology Follow-Up Studies Humans Infant Intubation, Gastrointestinal Intubation, Intratracheal Laryngeal Masks Larynx Male Respiration, Artificial Treatment Outcome airway conductance airway pressure monitor article child controlled study female fiber optics human infant laryngeal mask major clinical study male preschool child priority journal randomized controlled trial school child stomach tube
Background The laryngeal mask airway Supreme™ (Supreme) is a new single-use supraglottic device with gastric access capability now available in all sizes for children. Objectives To compare the i-gel™ with the Supreme in children for routine airway maintenance. Materials/Methods One hundred and seventy children, aged 3 months to 11 years, 5-50 kg in weight, were randomly assigned to receive either the i-gel™ or the Supreme. The primary outcome measured was airway leak pressure. Secondary outcomes included the following: ease and time for insertion, insertion success rate, fiberoptic grade of view, ease of gastric tube placement, number of airway manipulations, quality of airway during anesthetic maintenance, and complications. Results A total of 168 patients were assessed for the outcomes. The median (IQR [range]) airway leak pressure for the i-gel™ was higher than with the Supreme, 20 (18-25 [9-40]) cm H2O vs 17 (14-22 [10-40]) cm H2O, respectively (P = 0.001). There were no differences in the time for device insertion, fiberoptic grade of view, quality of airway, and complications. Median (IQR[range]) time of successful insertion of a gastric tube was faster with the Supreme, 12 (9.2-14.3 [5.2-44.2]) s than with the i-gel™, 14 (11.9-19 [6.9-75]) s; P = 0.01. The number of airway manipulations during placement was higher with the i-gel™ than with the laryngeal mask airway Supreme (12 vs 13 patients), P = 0.02. Conclusions In infants and children, when a single-use supraglottic device with gastric access capabilities is required, the i-gel™ demonstrated higher airway leak pressures and can be a useful alternative to the Supreme. © 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd.

Details

Logo image